• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Brooklyn Grill
  • Grilling Tools
    • Best Dishwashers & Guides
    • Best Griddles & Guides
    • Best Knives & Guides
    • Best Ovens & Guides
  • Grill Tips
    • Comparisons
  • Grill Recipes
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
You are here: Home / Grill Tips / How to make grilled cheese sandwich the best ways

How to make grilled cheese sandwich the best ways

June 13, 2022 by Keshi

The best morning should include beautiful weather, a hot cup of coffee, and a hearty breakfast. Do you have some bread, butter, and cheese in your pantry? Let’s make the best grilled cheese recipe! We’ll show you how to make grilled cheese sandwich and discuss other details that will make the dish more special.

How to make grilled cheese sandwich
Photo by Pixzolo Photography on Unsplash

Skip to Section

  • Grilled cheese sandwich recipes
  • Grilled cheese recipe gourmet
  • Calories for grilled cheese sandwich
  • The best cheese for a grilled cheese sandwich
  • The best bread for a grilled cheese sandwich
  • Tips for making the best grilled cheese recipe
    • Pick the freshest bread
    • Use butter generously
    • Layer the flavor
    • Grill the sandwich over low to medium heat
    • Cook the sandwich open faced first
  • How to reheat grilled cheese
  • Grilled cheese recipe FAQs
    • What can I add to the grilled cheese recipe?
    • Where should I cook grilled cheese?
    • Can I use mayo instead of butter?
    • Should I use grated or sliced cheese?
    • How thick should my bread be?
    • What side dish can be served with grilled cheese?
  • Conclusion

Grilled cheese sandwich recipes

The best grilled cheese recipe comes from the classic one where you only use butter, bread, and cheddar. Here is how to make grilled cheese sandwich the traditional way:

Ingredients:

  • Softened butter
  • Sliced sourdough bread
  • Shredded cheddar cheese

Procedure:

  1. Spread butter on each side of the sourdough slice.
  2. Top each side of bread with cheddar cheese, butter side down.
  3. Melt butter on a skillet over medium heat.
  4. Toast the bread, butter side down until golden brown and the cheese starts to melt.
  5. Flip the other slice of bread on top of the other and cook until the cheese completely melts for about 30 seconds.
  6. Remove from the pan and transfer to the plate then cut diagonally in half.

If you want to make a cheesier and more special sandwich. We have another grilled cheese sandwich recipe for you. Learn how to make a triple grilled cheese sandwich below:

Ingredients:

  • Softened butter
  • Sliced sourdough bread
  • Sliced cheddar cheese
  • Sliced Gouda cheese
  • Sliced Havarti cheese

Procedure:

  1. Spread butter on each side of the sourdough slice.
  2. Stack a piece of cheddar, Gouda, and Havarti cheese on each side of bread, butter side down.
  3. Melt butter on a skillet over medium heat.
  4. Toast the bread with the butter side down until golden brown and the cheese starts to melt. Do this for about 5 to 6 minutes.
  5. Flip the other slice of bread on top of the other and cook until the cheese completely melts for about 30 seconds.
  6. Remove from the pan and transfer to the plate then cut diagonally in half.

Grilled cheese recipe gourmet

Grilled cheese has been around since 1920. Now, the classic buttered toasted bread filled with cheese is made more special. Here’s how to make grilled cheese sandwich gourmet style:

Ingredients:

  • Softened butter
  • Mayonnaise
  • Sliced Artisan bread
  • Sliced Gruyere cheese
  • Sliced white cheddar cheese
  • Sliced Muenster cheese
  • Diced yellow onions
  • Minced fresh thyme
  • Minced fresh rosemary
  • Brown sugar
  • Salt and pepper
  • Olive oil

Procedure:

  1. Add butter and olive oil to a skillet and heat over medium temperature. Saute diced onions, fresh thyme and rosemary as well as salt and pepper for 10 minutes.
  2. Stir the brown sugar into the skillet and cook for another 1 minute. Then, transfer the onions onto a plate.
  3. Spread mayonnaise on each side of the sliced Artisan bread.
  4. Stack a piece of cheddar, Muenster, and Gruyere cheese on each side of bread, butter side down.
  5. Melt butter on a skillet over medium heat.
  6. Toast the bread, butter side down until golden brown and the cheese starts to melt. Do this for about 2 to 3 minutes.
  7. Flip the other slice of bread on top of the other and cook until the cheese completely melts for about 30 seconds.
  8. Remove from the pan and transfer to the plate then cut diagonally in half.
how to make grilled cheese sandwich
Photo by Pixzolo Photography on Unsplash

Calories for grilled cheese sandwich

According to My Food Data, a classic grilled cheese sandwich using American cheese on white bread contains 378 calories. These calories come from protein, fat, and carbs. Other nutrients you can get from eating grilled cheese sandwich are:

  • Fiber
  • Calcium
  • Vitamin D
  • Iron
  • Potassium
  • Phosphorus

The best cheese for a grilled cheese sandwich

Cheddar is the most popular cheese used for a grilled cheese recipe. However, the best cheese to use for this is low moisture cheese since they have the best melt. Look for American, pepper jack, or Monterey Jack. Don’t hesitate to use multiple cheeses if you have.

You can also use shredded cheese since it melts quicker and creates a better cheese pull than slices. If you can’t find a pre-shredded cheese, you can shred it yourself.

The best bread for a grilled cheese sandwich

Any bread can work if you are making a grilled cheese sandwich. If you are aiming for a crispy texture, make sure that the slice of bread you are using is not too thick. 

Moreover, use a bread that is neither airy nor dense. Airy bread will make the cheese ooze through while a dense one makes a heavy sandwich. If you are health-conscious, multigrain or whole wheat bread are some of the best choices for you. 

Tips for making the best grilled cheese recipe

Learning how to make grilled cheese sandwich is quick and easy but there are some useful tips that will make the dish more delicious. Take a look at some of them below:

Pick the freshest bread

The bread you should use for your grilled cheese depends entirely on your preference. Whatever it is, it is better if you use the freshest one. Moreover, avoid using thick slices since the cheese won’t melt properly.

Use butter generously

Don’t be shy in putting more butter on your toast since it will help give the sandwich a crispier texture.

Layer the flavor

A tip for those who want to take their grilled cheese recipe to a whole new level is to add more flavor. Use other ingredients such as fruits, vegetables, condiments and even jam. Here are some great combinations you might want to try:

  • Swiss cheese with tomatoes on whole-wheat bread
  • Cheddar, honey mustard, and apple slices on whole-grain bread
  • Goat cheese, tomato, and spinach on pita bread
  • Mozzarella, basil, and red bell pepper on whole-wheat bread
  • Manchego, grilled chicken, and BBQ sauce on sourdough bread
  • Cheddar, salsa, and spinach on sourdough bread

Grill the sandwich over low to medium heat

Making the best grilled cheese recipe takes a lot of patience to make. Make sure you keep your heat at low to medium to allow the cheese to fully melt and make the bread more golden and crispy. Turn the heat lower if you think the sandwich is browning too fast.

Cook the sandwich open faced first

Once you fill the slice of the bread with cheese, start cooking it without the top slice for a couple of minutes. The steam will help melt the cheese. Once the cheese melts, you can now add the top slice. Doing this will prevent the cheese from falling outside the bread, especially if you are using quite a lot.

How to reheat grilled cheese

Grilled cheese is best eaten for breakfast but if you have no time to sit down for it, you can always reheat it later. Typically, you can store the sandwich in the fridge for up to 5 days then reheat it on the skillet the same way as it was cooked. 

Although we don’t recommend doing this, you can also microwave the sandwich t if you are in a hurry. However, keep in mind that it will make the bread soft and soggy.

how to make grilled cheese sandwich
Photo by Asnim Ansari on Unsplash

Grilled cheese recipe FAQs

What can I add to the grilled cheese recipe?

You can add anything you want to your grilled cheese whether it is savory or sweet. Some people like to add bacon and ham while others add jam or brie for a sweeter taste. If you want to take your sandwich to a whole new level, try spreading some crunchy peanut butter for a sweet and salty combination.

Where should I cook grilled cheese?

Just because the name implies, grilled cheese is not actually grilled. You can still grill it, but make sure to keep the heat at a very low temperature to avoid burning the sandwich before the cheese completely melts. Use a non-stick pan or cast-iron skillet when cooking your grilled cheese. However, if you are cooking for many people, try using a flat cooktop or griddle.

Can I use mayo instead of butter?

It is up to your preference if you want mayo or butter since both can be used in grilled cheese. Some people prefer mayo since it is more convenient to spread. However, other people don’t like the taste of mayo. Keep in mind that if the convenience of spread is what you are looking for, you can always soften the butter first before spreading.

Should I use grated or sliced cheese?

Grated cheese melts quickly and evenly. Moreover, blending together different types of shredded cheeses is easier. Nevertheless, this does not indicate that using sliced cheese is a big no-no. You can still end up with a gooey grilled cheese sandwich even if you use sliced cheese.

How thick should my bread be?

Keep in mind that the thicker your bread slice is, the longer the cheese will melt. The optimal slice of bread ranges from ¼ inch to ½ inch thick. This will easily melt the cheese in as quick as 5 minutes.

What side dish can be served with grilled cheese?

Serving the classic tomato soup with grilled cheese is a great combination. But you can also serve salads, cooked greens, fruits, and vegetables as well.

Conclusion

Nothing beats the classic grilled cheese recipe that a lot of people love to eat any time of the day. All you need is just three ingredients and a skillet! There are many variations and tips on how to make a grilled cheese sandwich. However, don’t be afraid to follow your guts and make it based on your preferences!

Aside from grilled cheese recipes, we have a plethora of grilled recipes as well. At Brooklyn Grill, we cover everything grill-related from grill brands and tools to grilled recipes and grilling tips. 

Filed Under: Grill Tips, Grill Recipes

Previous Post: « Can you grill on a Traeger without smoke flavor?
Next Post: 10 Best Electric Smokers Consumer Reports 2022 »

Primary Sidebar

Follow Brooklyn Grill

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

About Brooklyn Grill

We are a team of grilling experts that try out the various grilling tools and accessories in The Brooklyn Grill restaurant to help you decide the most suitable for your needs. The team is also committed to providing you with grilling tips and guides, as well as the tastiest grill recipes. Learn more

Best Griddles

Bestseller No. 1 Presto 07061 22-inch Electric Griddle With Removable Handles, Black, 22-inch Presto 07061 22-inch Electric Griddle With... $49.99
Bestseller No. 2 Flat Top Griddle Grill Assembly Flat Top Griddle Grill Assembly $99.00
Bestseller No. 3 Blackstone New Version Cooking 4 Burner Flat Top Gas Grill Propane Fuelled Restaurant Grade Professional 36” Outdoor Griddle Station with Side Shelf, Black, 62.5 (L) x 22 (W) x 36 (H) inches(1554) Blackstone New Version Cooking 4 Burner Flat Top... $362.85

Best grills

SaleBestseller No. 1 Royal Gourmet GD401 Portable Propane Gas Grill and Griddle Combo with Side Table | 4-Burner, Folding Legs,Versatile, Outdoor | Black Royal Gourmet GD401 Portable Propane Gas Grill and... $243.25
Bestseller No. 2 Dual Fuel Gas & Charcoal Combo Grill, Black with Stainless, Stainless Steel (GBC1793W) Dual Fuel Gas & Charcoal Combo Grill, Black with... $265.50
Bestseller No. 3 Cuisinart CGG-7400 Propane, 54 Inch, Full Size Four-Burner Gas Grill Cuisinart CGG-7400 Propane, 54 Inch, Full Size... $308.13

Best dishwashers

SaleBestseller No. 1 Portable Countertop Dishwasher, 5 Washing Programs, Built-in 3-Cups Water Tank, 3D Cyclone Spray, Fruit & Vegetable Cleaning with Basket, High Temperature, Air Drying - Lights, Faucet Adapter Included Portable Countertop Dishwasher, 5 Washing... $278.00
SaleBestseller No. 2 COSMO COS-DIS6502 24 in. Top Control Built-In Tall Tub Dishwasher, Fingerprint Resistant, Low Noise 45dB in Stainless Steel COSMO COS-DIS6502 24 in. Top Control Built-In Tall... $749.99
Bestseller No. 3 Kalamera Built in Dishwasher, 24 inch Dishwacher with 14 Place Settings, 6 Wash Cycles and 4 Temperature Option, Energy Save with Low Water Consumption and Quiet Operation - Stainless Steel Kalamera Built in Dishwasher, 24 inch Dishwacher... $849.00

Best Ovens

Bestseller No. 1 Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Toaster Oven with Convection and Rotisserie, 6-Slice Bread/12-Inch Pizza, Black Stainless Steel Toshiba AC25CEW-BS Toaster Oven with Convection... $139.99
Bestseller No. 2 LUBY Large Toaster Oven Countertop, French Door Designed, 55L, 18 Slices, 14'' pizza, 20lb Turkey, Silver LUBY Large Toaster Oven Countertop, French Door... $153.74
Bestseller No. 3 Breville BOV860BSS Smart Oven Air Fryer, Countertop Convection Oven, Brushed Stainless Steel Breville BOV860BSS Smart Oven Air Fryer,... $349.95

Footer

Brooklyn Grill

We are a team of grilling experts that try out the various grilling tools and accessories in The Brooklyn Grill restaurant to help you decide the most suitable for your needs. The team is also committed to providing you with grilling tips and guides, as well as the tastiest grill recipes.

Important Pages

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE
  • Contact Us
  • About Us

Copyright © 2022 Brooklyn Grill on the Foodie Pro Theme